Don't Give Up on Kennedy

A lot of people are down on Ian Kennedy right now, and I can understand why. His performance yesterday was awful, and his comments after the game were pretty bad as well. However, it's way too early to write him off as a failed prospect. The problem is that people look at Kennedy as a guy who has failed as a major leaguer, and not as a guy who just isn't ready yet.

The fault, of course, lies with the Yankees, who pushed Kennedy into the majors far too quickly. Kennedy was drafted in 2006, and didn't sign until the middle of August. Over the next year he rocketed up the minors, pitching in five different leagues before making his major league debut on September 1, 2007. Even though he performed well, it's now obvious that he missed out on the education the minor leagues can provide.

Unfortunately, the minor league season ends in a few weeks, but the Yankees need to take advantage what time is left and send Kennedy back to Scranton. Once there, he's got to work on learning how to be a major league starter, which is a different task than just getting guys out. For example, he might face a batter who he could get out with a curveball out of the strikezone, but if that's a pitch a major league hitter wouldn't swing at, then he shouldn't throw it. Instead, he needs to try and make the kinds of pitches that would get a major leaguer out. Doing so might lead to some mistakes and some extra runs, but those are the kinds of learning experiences a player is supposed to get in the minor leagues, and until Kennedy gets them, you can't just write him off.