Options

It's been a dull week in Yankee land, with only a few small stories worth mentioning. The biggest news was the team's exercising their $16 million option to bring Bobby Abreu back for another season. Of course, this wasn't news at all, since Brian Cashman has for weeks implied that that was what he was going to do. Normally, I'd say that that $16 million would be better spent on something other than an aging right fielder whose production has been declining for the past few years. However, with A-Rod gone the Yankees have the money to spare, and the alternatives aren't that good. Without Abreu, the Yankees would either have to use Shelley Duncan, who's a good platoon player but not good enough to play every day, or downgrade their defense by moving Melky Cabrera to right and Johnny Damon to center. Of course the team could go the free agent route, but the pickings are pretty slim. The only possible free agent who I think would be a better choice than Abreu is Kosuke Fukudome.

Fukudome (whose name is pronounced Koh-skay Foo-koo-DOH-may), is the star right fielder for the Chunichi Dragons of the Japanese League. He's a patient hitter, with doubles power, posting a career line of .305/.397/.543 (AVG/OBP/SLG), and .329/.435/.600 over the past three seasons. Defensively, he's reported to be excellent. His speed and instincts are both above average, which makes for great range, and his arm is both strong and accurate. American fans may remember him from the World Baseball Classic last year, where he proved himself to be a clutch performer by hitting pivotal late inning home runs in both the semi-finals and finals.

Looking at how Japanese hitters have performed in the majors, I think Fukodome would perform significantly better than the declining Abreu, and would do so for less money (he's expected to cost around $12 million a year for three or four years and, as an unrestricted free agent, there would be no posting fee). That said, there's no guarantee that the Yankees would be able to sign him, and I can't fault Cashman for taking the sure thing. Plus, he now has the option of trading Abreu if he does try to sign Fukudome, much as he did with Gary Sheffield (though I'm not entirely sure if Abreu's no-trade clause is still in effect after he waived it last year).

In other option news, Andy Pettitte has declined his $16 million option for next season. According to his agent, he did so because the deadline came up and he needed more time to consider his future. However, he also said that his future consists of only two options; the Yankees or retirement, and he's not looking for more money. While the A-Rod circus might make you cynical about a player being honest in these situations, Pettitte's a stand up guy, and there's no reason to think that he doesn't mean what he's saying. It'd be better for the Yankees to know whether he'll be in their rotation, but you have to respect Pettitte's need to weigh his decision. I really do hope he comes back, but either way I wish him the best.